« Website Update - Top 10 Page List Updated for Past 4 Months | Main | Proposition 8 »

Genetic Determinism

DNAI got into a discussion with a few co-workers last week on a topic that I'd thought most educated people agreed upon to a large extent - the limits of genetic determinism. In the old argument of nature vs. nurture, I thought most people realized that who we are is a combination of both influences. However, in that conversation, I was the only one who thought environment played a big role, while the other two thought it was mostly down to genetics. Anyway, a few days after our conversation, I sent them an e-mail explaining how environment can contribute to our traits, and decided that it might be worth posting a modified version of it here on the blog. So, to anyone who puts too much stock in genetic determinism, here's some information on how environment also plays a strong role in our development.

First, there's an example that's so obvious that we almost forget about it - muscle size. Genetics gives us a potential muscle size & strength, but our actual muscle size can be greatly affected by diet and lifestyle, particularly by being active or working out. This is a clear example of genetics and environment interacting to produce a trait.

Here's an article on height (since that was one of the traits my coworkers and I discussed specifically). Based on studies between twins and other relatives, it looks like genetics is 60 to 80% responsible for height, and environmental factors, particularly nutrition, are responsible for the remaining 20 to 40%.
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=how-much-of-human-height

Here are a couple more links on height.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_height
http://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/askasci/mle00/mole00125.htm
http://jn.nutrition.org/cgi/content/full/135/9/2192

One important caveat on twins that doesn't get mentioned in many of these articles - identical twins don't look so similar solely because of their shared genetics (although that is the biggest reason). It is also due to the shared environment in the womb. That's why fraternal twins look more similar that siblings that didn't develop together. So, it's not enough to look at identical twins in these studies - you have to use fraternal twins as a control for early developmental factors.


Here's a really good site on the 'nature vs. nurture' debate that focuses on intelligence. I'm giving the link to the conclusion, but if you follow the links on the site, you can find the evidence they list. To quote part of that site:

Through the research we have done, it seems that heredity, as well as environment plays an important role in humans’ mentality; but these are not exactly equal in influence. A person’s entire environment seems to be more effectual in determining his mental ability than heredity is. The most fundamental way to explain our opinion is quite comprehensible. It is that heredity determines one’s potential, but environment determines how far one will reach that potential during his lifetime. In other words, every individual has a destined mental potential, but how much of that potential the individual will be able to gain solely depends on the environment that the individual grows in.

http://www.macalester.edu/psychology/whathap/ubnrp/intelligence05/Rconclusion.html


Here's another article that touches briefly on genetic determinism, mentioning an experiment where cloned plants (i.e. genetically identical) were grown in different environments, and the plants grew differently depending on the environment they were in.
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2009/10/richard_lewontingenetic_determ.php


Another point against genetic determinism is the fact that our cells aren't perfect machines, where given inputs give precise outputs. Cells are a cluttered stew of molecules inside a membrane. Depending on how molecules are dispersed throughout the cell, two genetically identical cells may have different reactions to the same conditions. Carl Zimmer's book, Microcosm, has a good explanation of this, if you ever get a chance to read it. A good example, one which made headlines, is the first cloned cat. Although it has identical nuclear DNA to its mother, it has a different color pattern, because the activation and inactivation of the responsible genes is more or less random.
http://www.accessexcellence.org/WN/SU/copycat.php


Here are two more links, dealing with related themes that we discussed. The first link is to an article on the Flynn Effect (the fact that IQ scores have been increasing). We also discussed abstract thinking, and whether or not it's a learned skill. The second link below includes a discussion of a study done in Uzbekistan which seems to confirm that abstract thinking is learned (though the article also mentions potential problems with the study).
http://www.americanscientist.org/bookshelf/pub/the-domestication-of-the-savage-mind
http://www.cscs.umich.edu/~crshalizi/slothblog/484.html


Okay, so what's my point in all this? Genetics plays a significant role in who we are, but so do environmental factors, and even random chance has a part. So, given the long complicated history that has led to the current conditions in the world, unless two people have had very similar upbringings, it would be nearly impossible to tell how much of the difference between them was due to genetics.

Comments

atorvastatin 10mg price order atorvastatin 40mg for sale atorvastatin 20mg oral

order ciprofloxacin 500mg pills - order myambutol 600mg for sale clavulanate canada

ciprofloxacin oral - buy cephalexin 125mg generic augmentin 375mg

flagyl order online - amoxicillin ca generic azithromycin 250mg

buy ciplox 500 mg without prescription - buy doryx pill buy erythromycin pills for sale

valacyclovir 1000mg tablet - buy nateglinide 120mg online acyclovir 400mg uk

buy ivermectin 6 mg online - cheap ciprofloxacin tetracycline 500mg canada

purchase metronidazole - buy cleocin sale zithromax 500mg ca

order ampicillin for sale ampicillin price buy generic amoxil over the counter

buy furosemide 100mg sale - atacand uk buy captopril generic

glycomet 1000mg for sale - bactrim 960mg us order lincocin 500mg for sale

how to get zidovudine without a prescription - buy zyloprim medication

clozaril 100mg canada - buy cheap generic pepcid pepcid cheap

seroquel 50mg canada - buy generic desyrel over the counter purchase eskalith online

clomipramine 25mg for sale - order cymbalta 20mg generic buy doxepin pills

buy atarax 10mg online - buy endep 10mg online cheap order amitriptyline 25mg online

buy amoxicillin tablets - erythromycin 500mg cost baycip without prescription

buy generic amoxiclav - order generic myambutol cheap cipro 1000mg

buy cheap clindamycin - order terramycin 250mg how to buy chloromycetin

cost zithromax 250mg - tinidazole 500mg ca order ciplox 500mg pill

ivermectin 12 mg stromectol - brand cefaclor 250mg buy cefaclor medication

purchase albuterol without prescription - theo-24 Cr for sale theo-24 Cr 400 mg cost

order desloratadine 5mg online cheap - buy beclomethasone nasal sprays albuterol 2mg tablet

methylprednisolone 8mg tablets - purchase montelukast generic buy azelastine sprayer

micronase medication - order forxiga 10 mg order generic forxiga

prandin order online - buy generic empagliflozin over the counter order empagliflozin 25mg for sale

metformin tablet - buy generic sitagliptin over the counter precose uk

lamisil cost - order grifulvin v generic purchase griseofulvin

how to buy rybelsus - purchase glucovance generic buy desmopressin without prescription

order ketoconazole 200mg pills - buy sporanox pills purchase itraconazole generic

famvir 250mg over the counter - order valcivir 1000mg online cheap buy cheap generic valaciclovir

lanoxin online order - dipyridamole 25mg us order lasix for sale

microzide 25 mg over the counter - buy lisinopril 2.5mg generic zebeta 5mg cheap

purchase metoprolol online cheap - inderal 10mg for sale adalat 10mg usa

nitroglycerin where to buy - nitroglycerin cost valsartan 160mg usa

zocor watcher - lipitor desert atorvastatin raft

crestor hour - caduet online parlour caduet assistant

acne treatment darken - acne treatment objection acne medication party

asthma medication tea - inhalers for asthma oxford asthma medication dare

uti treatment crumble - treatment for uti shut uti medication bosom

pills for treat prostatitis ease - prostatitis medications title prostatitis pills serve

Post a comment


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.jefflewis.net/blog/jlnet-tb.cgi/319

Archives

Selling Out