« Updated Casio EX-F1 Review | Main | Friday Bible Blogging - Hiatus »

Eben Alexander Follow-Up

Eben AlexanderNot too long ago, I wrote an article titled Eben Alexander Misrepresenting Carl Sagan, where I described how Alexander had completely misrepresented one of Sagan's positions from his book, The Demon Haunted World. Like I wrote then, it's not just the fact that he made a mistake that was troubling, but that he did it with such supreme confidence, even citing the page number.

I just happened to notice that on Alexander's personal blog, in the comments to his post, Post Debate Reflections: The Sound of One Hand Clapping, somebody called him out for this misrepresentation. Here was Alexander's chance to admit his mistake and apologize, but instead he responded with this comment of his own.

Just an honest attempt to remember something I had recently read - I was actually surprised I remembered the page number perfectly. I remembered recently reading the quote and being quite astonished that Carl Sagan, in his opinion, stated that the evidence for reincarnation, based on young children remembering details of a previous life, deserves serious study. That is striking. Sorry I used the word "overwhelming," but if you stop to think about exactly what Carl Sagan said, it should impress you significantly (why split hairs over "overwhelming" vs "deserves serious study"?). Novella said "I've read that book a hundred times" (really? 100?), and "That is just not true." He told me backstage that he had read that book several times and that he did not remember that quote at all, yet the next day he posted on his blog that I was correct, that the statement was on page 302 as I had remembered (minus the word "overwhelming"). The evidence is more powerful now than that of which Sagan was aware - read Jim Tucker's 2013 book "Return to Life: Extraordinary Cases of Children who remember Past Lives." Extraordinary evidence supporting this reality -- to simply deny it outright is to be willfully ignorant.

This is no longer an oral debate relying solely on memory. Alexander can go look at Sagan's quote. He no longer has any excuse for misrepresenting Sagan, but he still does. If you don't feel like reading my old entry, here is just one portion of the Sagan passage that I quoted to remind you of his position.

I pick these claims not because I think they're likely to be valid (I don't), but as examples of contentions that might be true. The last three have at least some, although still dubious, experimental support.

It's not splitting hairs or just dropping the word 'overwhelming'. Sagan didn't think the evidence was at all strong for 'past life memories in children', but just barely worth further study on the off chance that it might be true. It was the general scientific mindset of always being open to new evidence.

Further, Alexander misrepresented what Novella wrote in the entry Alexander was referring to, After the Afterlife Debate. Whereas Alexander thinks, "yet the next day he posted on his blog that I was correct, that the statement was on page 302 as I had remembered (minus the word 'overwhelming').", Novella himself wrote of Alexander's interpretation of the quote, "That's pretty thin gruel on which Alexander is hanging his hat." Novella was calling out Alexander for misrepresenting Sagan, not admitting that Alexander was largely right.

At first, I thought Alexander's problem was a simple mistake coupled with over-confidence, which was bad enough. But now after reading this, it seems like the real problem might be integrity.


order atorvastatin 20mg for sale buy generic atorvastatin 10mg lipitor canada

buy cipro pill - buy bactrim tablets augmentin brand

cipro sale - buy augmentin 375mg online cheap how to get clavulanate without a prescription

ciplox buy online - purchase erythromycin pill buy erythromycin cheap

flagyl 200mg brand - metronidazole 200mg tablet cheap zithromax

cost of stromectol - axetil pill how to buy sumycin

order valacyclovir 500mg generic - buy valacyclovir 500mg pill oral acyclovir 800mg

acillin drug buy generic amoxil purchase amoxil generic

metronidazole tablet - flagyl online order buy zithromax without prescription

buy lasix 100mg online - minipress 1mg without prescription order captopril pill

order generic glycomet - combivir ca lincomycin 500mg sale

retrovir buy online - buy generic zyloprim oral zyloprim 100mg

buy clozapine pills - generic frumil pepcid us

quetiapine 100mg cheap - trazodone 50mg tablet cheap eskalith sale

oral anafranil 25mg - oral mirtazapine 30mg pill sinequan 75mg

buy atarax 10mg without prescription - order buspirone online buy endep 10mg generic

buy clavulanate medication - oral zyvox 600mg buy cipro 500mg pill

buy amoxicillin without a prescription - buy cefadroxil 250mg pill purchase baycip online cheap

buy generic zithromax online - tinidazole order ciprofloxacin price

buy clindamycin tablets - purchase acticlate online cheap cheap chloromycetin online

ivermectin 12mg for people - buy levaquin online cefaclor cost

albuterol inhalator order - order fluticasone online cheap buy theo-24 Cr without prescription

methylprednisolone 16mg for sale - buy loratadine without a prescription astelin usa

clarinex pills - cost flixotide cost ventolin inhalator

glycomet sale - order losartan pill order precose 25mg without prescription

cost prandin 2mg - jardiance pill empagliflozin 25mg for sale

buy semaglutide without a prescription - buy desmopressin without a prescription desmopressin online buy

where to buy terbinafine without a prescription - buy fulvicin 250mg online cheap how to buy griseofulvin

buy nizoral generic - order mentax buy sporanox 100 mg pill

buy famvir 500mg pills - buy cheap famciclovir order valcivir 1000mg online

order lanoxin 250 mg generic - brand labetalol furosemide 40mg pills

lopressor 50mg generic - metoprolol 100mg pills generic nifedipine

buy microzide 25mg without prescription - order hydrochlorothiazide sale zebeta 10mg generic

nitroglycerin for sale - cheap diovan 80mg valsartan buy online

simvastatin farmer - lopid lip lipitor grave

rosuvastatin online roof - zetia inner caduet online faint

asthma medication capture - asthma medication bed asthma treatment ourself

acne treatment size - acne medication thorough acne medication health

prostatitis medications skill - prostatitis medications gather pills for treat prostatitis anyone

uti treatment reduce - uti medication quarrel uti medication dread

Post a comment


TrackBack URL for this entry:


Selling Out