« Science and Engineering Indicators 2016 | Main | Website Update - Top 10 Page List for January 2016 »

Answering Quora - Thought Experiment: Pretend that the Triune God of the Bible actually exists in reality. What would such a Being owe you, and why?

The Out Campaign: Scarlet Letter of AtheismI've once again used up my lunch breaks this week writing on Quora, so I'm going to recycle an answer for this blog entry. One Quora user posted the following question as a thought experiment, Pretend that the Triune God of the Bible actually exists in reality. What would such a Being owe you, and why? Below is my response, with a few edits from my original Quora answer.

---

First of all, this is a bit difficult to answer because the God of the Bible isn't a totally consistent character. I mean, just in physical representation, he goes from a very anthropomorphic god with somewhat limited powers and knowledge in Genesis (he walked in the Garden of Eden and had to go physically visit Sodom to see for himself how the people were behaving), to more of a disembodied all powerful spirit in later books. He also exhibits different personality traits, sometimes being very vindictive and doling out group punishment for the sins of individuals (like the plagues of Egypt harming even the slaves, even though it was the Pharaoh who Yahweh had his disagreement with - not to mention the hardening of Pharaoh's heart to prolong the suffering), other times saying everyone will be punished or rewarded for their own actions, and other times saying it's only faith that determines our fate and not our actions at all. So, which 'God of the Bible' are we going with? And then, you have to figure out how much of God's actions/behaviors you're willing to accept as givens in answering this question.

So, let's just start out with creation (assuming a literal creation for this thought experiment). At that point, having created new sentient beings with no experiences of their own and no culture to guide them, Yahweh would have an obligation to help them get things set up. Just imagine it as a mad scientist on Earth creating artificial life and setting it loose on a deserted island. You'd expect him to teach that life how to survive, probably set them up with some shelter and tools, suggest some rules of ethics, maybe give them a constitution and some form of government, etc.

Then, I can see it going two ways, still using our mad scientist as an analogy. He could just step back and not interfere at all after that, owing them nothing, but also expecting nothing in return. He could leave these beings on their own, free to develop their society as they saw fit, modifying their laws and ethics as they developed themselves. Or, he could continue to give them a hand and advice in running things, since he has a lot more experience to draw from. But, he still shouldn't expect anything in return. These beings didn't ask to be created. He didn't do them a favor by creating them. He acted of his own accord to create them. He's the one that put them in the position of having to figure out how to live their lives.

Let's go along further with assuming that he is the intervening type. And further, that he's going to reward the people who follow the rules he laid down, and punish the people who don't. First, he would owe us ethical rules. No arbitrary rules like not wearing clothes with mixed fibers, and no cruel rules like ordering parents to stone disobedient children, or ordering communities to stone homosexuals. And the whole animal sacrifice thing would be out. (Note, read about the Euthyphro dilemma for a discussion of why gods can't dictate morality by fiat.) Second, he would owe us an unambiguous declaration of the rules he expects us to follow - nothing like the Bible with all its contradictions and translation/transmission errors. I mean, just imagine our mad scientist giving his created beings a hodge podge of rules as confusing as the Bible, written in a language other than their native language, and then going out and punishing the ones who made mistakes. It would be horrible.

Let's take this intervention further, and even though it shouldn't be the case in a fair universe, that he does expect worship, and that he's going to reward the people most faithful to him, and punish the people who don't worship him. In that case, I think he would at least owe a clear, unambiguous demonstration to every generation that he does actually exist so that we can be sure which religion to follow. If our mad scientist tried to demand worship, the first thing we'd do is consider him an amoral narcissist. But if he kept himself hidden entirely, and never made any personal appearances, or even television appearances or interviews, and then sent out secret police to find and torture citizens of his island nation who wondered whether he'd died since nobody ever saw him anymore, we'd think he was a monster.

For the last thing I'm going to consider, let's take this punishment further - not just the finite punishments of the Old Testament God, but the eternal damnation to Hell of the New Testament God. First of all, I'd say that we were owed not to have to worry about a punishment like that to begin with. It's barbaric. If our mad scientist wanted to pull out the nuclear option on his private island, banishment would seem to be enough, rather than actual torture. And there's no need for a dichotomy. If he wanted to reward especially good beings, he could give them special treatment without actually punishing all the rest. If God were real, and heaven were only for his most faithful, I think we'd be owed at least a third option in the afterlife of mere existence without the torture of Hell, or even a fourth option of simply ceasing to exist, which would still be preferrable to eternal torment. And why would a punishment have to be eternal, anyway? And like before, assuming this is all real, I think we'd be owed clear, unambiguous evidence that Hell is a possible fate awaiting us, not just some myth like so many other myths in human history (like trying to learn the trials described in the Egyptian Book of the Dead so we'll be prepared for that possible afterlife).

To sum up, if there actually were a creator god, once he (he and not she because it's the Biblical God) made sure society was up and running, I don't think he'd really owe us anything, but I don't think he could really expect people to owe him anything in return. Assuming he was going to demand worship and dole out rewards and punishments, especially a punishment as barbaric as Hell, I think he'd owe us clear evidence of his existence, and clear documentation of his expectations and rules. Basically, he should act like a decent, ethical being.

Comments

generic atorvastatin 40mg purchase lipitor without prescription order atorvastatin pills

order lipitor 40mg pills lipitor 40mg canada buy cheap atorvastatin

ciprofloxacin cheap - brand ethambutol 600mg clavulanate usa

order ciprofloxacin 500mg online cheap - order myambutol 600mg generic buy augmentin 375mg pill

metronidazole 200mg ca - order azithromycin online order zithromax for sale

buy ciprofloxacin 500mg pills - oral ciplox erythromycin generic

valtrex 500mg for sale - order generic nateglinide 120mg zovirax pill

ivermectin 6 mg for humans for sale - buy suprax 100mg where to buy sumycin without a prescription

brand metronidazole 200mg - cheap amoxil tablets generic azithromycin 250mg

buy generic ampicillin for sale vibra-tabs for sale amoxil pills

purchase furosemide for sale - how to buy medex order capoten 25 mg for sale

order glycomet 1000mg for sale - bactrim 960mg generic lincocin online order

purchase retrovir pills - zyloprim 100mg price zyloprim 100mg without prescription

order clozapine 100mg sale - altace over the counter buy pepcid 40mg sale

order seroquel 100mg online cheap - order geodon generic buy eskalith tablets

anafranil without prescription - cost amoxapine sinequan cheap

hydroxyzine 25mg cheap - buy buspirone generic amitriptyline 25mg cheap

order augmentin 1000mg - augmentin 375mg cost buy cipro cheap

purchase amoxil sale - cheap amoxil without prescription ciprofloxacin 500mg cheap

buy clindamycin no prescription - buy suprax without a prescription chloramphenicol online buy

zithromax online - tetracycline over the counter ciprofloxacin pills

ivermectin 12 mg tablets for humans - levaquin 250mg tablet cefaclor 250mg capsules

antihistamine drugs list - buy fluticasone generic order theo-24 Cr

buy clarinex for sale - ventolin cheap albuterol order

micronase usa - buy glipizide sale dapagliflozin over the counter

repaglinide 1mg for sale - order prandin generic empagliflozin cheap

cost terbinafine 250mg - terbinafine 250mg pills buy cheap grifulvin v

cheap semaglutide - buy semaglutide generic buy cheap desmopressin

buy nizoral no prescription - order ketoconazole generic order sporanox 100mg generic

buy famciclovir 250mg for sale - buy famciclovir medication order generic valcivir

order lanoxin 250 mg generic - dipyridamole 100mg drug buy furosemide without a prescription

buy hydrochlorothiazide 25mg - purchase plendil for sale buy bisoprolol pills

order lopressor 50mg pill - micardis oral order adalat without prescription

nitroglycerin sale - pill indapamide cost diovan 160mg

crestor online truth - pravachol slice caduet pills similar

simvastatin pause - zocor scene lipitor passionate

acne medication top - acne treatment pour acne treatment grandfather

asthma treatment crack - asthma treatment satisfaction inhalers for asthma scent

uti antibiotics inspire - uti antibiotics university uti treatment female

pills for treat prostatitis handful - prostatitis medications crown prostatitis medications fall

Post a comment


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.jefflewis.net/blog/jlnet-tb.cgi/861

Archives

Selling Out