« Commenting Change (Hopefully Temporary) | Main | Wright Brothers Day »

Texas Education Agency - Chris Comer

I've been very late in blogging about this - the story broke a couple weeks ago. Chris Comer, the director of science curriculum for the Texas Education Agency resigned. There's still a fair amount of controversy surrounding this. Many are quick to jump to the conclusion, which is based on Comer's side of the story, that her resignation was forced because of her support for evolution. In particular, she forwarded on an e-mail announcing a talk by Barbara Forrest, author of "Inside Creationism's Trojan Horse," and a key witness in the Dover trial, which prompted an e-mail from Lizzette Reynolds calling for her to be fired:

This is highly inappropriate. I believe this is an offense that calls for termination or, at the very least, reassignment of responsibilities. This is something that the State Board, the Governor's Office and members of the Legislature would be extremely upset to see because it assumes this is a subject that the agency supports.

Well, I would hope the agency supports sound science teaching, but this e-mail wasn't an official TEA statement, so I'll move on. It was very soon after this that Comer was forced to resign, and the memo recommending her termination included the FYI e-mail as one of its reasons. So, it seems that her support of science was a big reason for her forced recommendation, but the only reason I'm holding out is because of the list of other reasons given in that memo. Comer and others called those other reasons trumped up charges, which they might very well be, but call me naive, I just really want to give people the benefit of the doubt, so I'm not going to assume that the people at the TEA are that malicious.

So, I'll hold off judgement on why Comer was fired, but another statement from the memo does damn the school board:

Ms. Comer's e-mail implies endorsement of the speaker and implies that TEA endorses the speaker's position on a subject on which the agency must remain neutral.

Must remain neutral?! Looks like Reynolds' statement wasn't so far off from what the TEA board thought as a whole. But it's all ludicrous. Isn't the TEA's whole raison d'etre to provide quality education to students? How can remaining neutral on the issue of science vs. pseudoscience be fulfilling that mission? What if Comer had forwarded an e-mail about a lecturer addressing issues of holocaust deniers or HIV denialists - is the TEA to remain neutral on pseudohistory and pseudomedicine as well?

Given that the current chairman of the Texas State Board of Education, Don McLeroy, is a creationist (who doubts anthropogenic global climate change, to boot), and in the past has openly advocated Intelligent Design and old school creationism in the classroom (heck, you don't even need to look at his opponents - just go visit McLeroy's own site to see the type of craziness he believes in), and considering that school science standards are coming up for review in 2008, it makes Comer's resignation all the more fishy. I think everyone in this state needs to keep a close eye on how things play out in the coming months.

Much more information on this whole affair can be found at the website of the National Center for Science Education.


lipitor canada buy lipitor 40mg for sale order atorvastatin 20mg online

order ciprofloxacin 500mg for sale - buy cephalexin 125mg amoxiclav for sale

purchase baycip pill - brand septra augmentin pills

purchase metronidazole - order metronidazole without prescription buy cheap azithromycin

ciplox ca - doxycycline pill erythromycin 500mg oral

valtrex 1000mg canada - diltiazem usa brand acyclovir 400mg

ivermectin 12 mg tablets - generic amoxiclav purchase sumycin for sale

generic metronidazole 200mg - order amoxil for sale azithromycin 500mg sale

ampicillin online buy penicillin canada amoxicillin drug

order furosemide 40mg - capoten 25 mg ca purchase capoten generic

buy glucophage 500mg pill - combivir for sale online order lincocin 500mg online cheap

zidovudine 300 mg without prescription - buy cheap generic avalide purchase allopurinol pills

clozaril 50mg cheap - buy aceon cheap famotidine 40mg price

quetiapine 50mg us - buy quetiapine pills eskalith buy online

hydroxyzine pills - buspar 5mg cost endep 10mg pill

buy clomipramine 25mg online cheap - buy cheap generic tofranil order sinequan 25mg generic

amoxicillin pills - order duricef 500mg online ciprofloxacin 500mg uk

augmentin 1000mg brand - buy generic zyvox ciprofloxacin order online

buy cleocin medication - cleocin 300mg drug chloramphenicol price

purchase zithromax for sale - buy sumycin 250mg pill ciprofloxacin 500mg cheap

oral albuterol 2mg - purchase fluticasone without prescription buy theophylline pills for sale

buy ivermectin 3mg - generic cefaclor 250mg purchase cefaclor pills

clarinex pill - flixotide ca purchase albuterol inhalator online

oral medrol cost - buy azelastine nasal spray astelin 10 ml canada

purchase glyburide for sale - glucotrol 10mg over the counter forxiga order

order generic prandin 2mg - buy jardiance 25mg generic where can i buy empagliflozin

buy glucophage 1000mg sale - order losartan 25mg online cheap buy precose 25mg generic

buy lamisil tablets - order fulvicin purchase grifulvin v generic

semaglutide brand - glucovance over the counter order DDAVP generic

purchase ketoconazole online - mentax online buy itraconazole 100mg usa

order lanoxin generic - generic dipyridamole 25mg buy lasix 100mg for sale

purchase famciclovir for sale - how to buy famvir valcivir 500mg without prescription

order microzide 25mg online cheap - purchase prinivil pill order zebeta

order metoprolol 50mg generic - cost cozaar nifedipine where to buy

buy nitroglycerin online cheap - nitroglycerin cheap buy valsartan 160mg pill

rosuvastatin another - pravastatin bear caduet buy release

simvastatin abrupt - fenofibrate quill lipitor generous

acne treatment jim - acne treatment odour acne treatment chair

inhalers for asthma shelf - asthma treatment morrow asthma treatment beast

uti medication holiday - uti treatment spider uti treatment truth

prostatitis treatment deal - prostatitis pills slam prostatitis pills definite

Post a comment


TrackBack URL for this entry:


Selling Out