« Book Review- City of Ember | Main | Book Review- Gulliver's Travels »

Shenanigans in the Texas State Board of Education

TEA LogoThis is a story that's already made its way around the skeptical neighborhoods of the blogosphere, but it definitely bears repeating for anybody that hasn't heard it yet. Last Friday, the Texas State Board of Education approved the new English Language Arts and Reading curriculum standards.

According to the news release put out by the Texas Education Agency,

A less repetitive, more grade-level specific set of English Language Arts and Reading curriculum standards will go into use in Texas classrooms in the fall of 2009 after having been approved by the State Board of Education May 23 on a 9-6 vote.

The process of revising the 1997 standards began in 2005. Hundreds of teachers, numerous experts, national facilitators, and State Board of Education members worked on many drafts of the document over that time.

The standards ultimately approved by the board represent a blending of a document crafted by teacher work groups, with the help of facilitators from StandardsWork, and a version drafted by a coalition of English teachers. Many of the same teachers worked on both documents.



That release also states

Other board expressed strong concerns about being asked to approve a draft document that emerged on the final day of deliberations. Consequently, the board agreed to go through the document page by page, spending several hours looking at the latest revisions.

After working two and a half years on curriculum standards, I can imagine that board members would have "strong concerns" over a document that they'd had less than a day to review. There's an article in the Dallas Morning News that lists more details of how that document was released:

"I find it's really wild that we can work for three years on a project and then the board is so qualified they can pull it out of their hat overnight," said board member Pat Hardy, a Fort Worth Republican who, like other board members, received the substituted document when it was slipped under her hotel door less than an hour before their meeting was set to convene Friday morning.

The article also discusses how the "seveal hours" were spent reviewing the new document.

After first saying he would not give board members time to go over the new document during the meeting, Chairman Don McLeroy, a Republican from College Station, eventually relented, allowing a quick run through of the new document with an explanation of the changes.

But the squabbling did not end there.

"Mr. Chair you're going so fast ... you're moving so fast we can't find it in the other document," Berlanga said, shortly after the page-by-page explanation began.

After more complaints, McLeroy declared that he would continue at the fast pace.

"The ruling is you're being dilatory in dragging this out," McLeroy said.

The Houston Chronicle also has an article on what happened, with an opening paragraph that sums up the situation quite nicely.

A three-year effort to rewrite English language arts and reading standards for the state's public schools came down to a last minute cut-and-paste job Friday.

The way the Board of Education handled this was completely improper. Don McLeroy, the head of the Board of Education (who also happens to be a creationist, and a dentist, with virtually no qualifications for heading that board) should resign, and if he doesn't do so voluntarily, should be removed by the governor.

And don't forget that the science standards are the next in line to be reviewed. If the board can be so underhanded on a topic as uncontroversial as English, I fear just what stunts they're going to pull when it comes to subjects like biology and geology.

The best write up I've seen of this in the blogosphere comes from Phil Plait's Bad Astronomy Blog

Comments

As much as I think Mcleroy is a douche, I'm curious what exactly was changed. They say it was changed "overnight", but they never say how major or minor the changes were. If they added a completely new draft in one night then that is seriously wrong. If it was just a few minor typos and other slight changes then I don't see the problem. I still see a problem with the way he acted though, there is no reason not to spend the necesary time to review the changes. The way he rushed through everything and the fact that other board members got very angry suggests that he actually is doing something shady though. My kids only have a few years until they start schooling. If all of this isn't better (or dog forbid worse), then we'll probably end up moving. I actually really like Texas, but it seems the education may be going completely down hill.

Oh, I almost forgot. Here is the link to all of the board members. I think you and I are actually in the same district, #14 with Gail Lowe. Maybe with our two votes combinded... lol ... I'm working on finding out more about her, not sure who's side she is on.

Another good site to use is:
http://www.fyi.legis.state.tx.us/

You can find all your Texas representatives on it.


According to the TEA's own press release:

The standards ultimately approved by the board represent a blending of a document crafted by teacher work groups, with the help of facilitators from StandardsWork, and a version drafted by a coalition of English teachers.

It wasn't just typos and minor changes. It was copying and pasting sections from two different documents. Without adequate time for review, who knows just what parts exactly got put in, what parts got left out, and even if anything else was inserted. The standards may turn out to be okay, but this certainly wasn't the proper procedure for a public institution to follow.

As far as sending your kids to a TX public school, my daughter's education has been pretty good so far. Plus, the way I look at it, school's just a foundation, not the totality of her education. I make sure to teach her quite a bit on my own outside of school. Still, with what's been going on with the BOE and TEA (don't forget about the Comer affair), I think I'm going to have to start becoming more active in local politics.

Oh, and Lowe is my rep on the BOE.

It wasn't just typos and minor changes. It was copying and pasting sections from two different documents. Without adequate time for review, who knows just what parts exactly got put in, what parts got left out, and even if anything else was inserted. The standards may turn out to be okay, but this certainly wasn't the proper procedure for a public institution to follow.
It's unfortunate that was how it was actually handled. I agree it's completely irresponsible. I was hoping it was just typos, etc.

I agree about being more active in politics, but if my voice is a drop in a bucket and things get too bad, then I'll have to go somewhere that I'm more in agreement with. I'm glad to hear that your daughter's foundational learning is good though. It would be a shame to only learn to socialize at school.

brand lipitor 20mg lipitor price lipitor online order

atorvastatin 80mg without prescription buy atorvastatin 40mg pills lipitor us

cipro order - buy sulfamethoxazole pills augmentin 1000mg pills

cipro price - cheap augmentin augmentin 1000mg canada

buy generic flagyl for sale - flagyl 200mg oral order azithromycin 250mg without prescription

buy ciprofloxacin online - doxycycline uk purchase erythromycin pill

ivermectin 3mg without a doctor prescription - purchase amoxiclav online buy sumycin generic

valtrex 500mg us - buy valtrex 500mg without prescription cost acyclovir

flagyl 400mg cheap - oxytetracycline medication buy azithromycin online

oral ampicillin penicillin uk purchase amoxil for sale

furosemide 100mg without prescription - lasix pill captopril 25mg ca

glycomet online order - buy cefadroxil 500mg sale lincocin 500mg over the counter

zidovudine cost - buy zyloprim sale buy zyloprim 100mg online cheap

buy clozapine 50mg generic - order clozapine 100mg without prescription buy famotidine generic

buy quetiapine 50mg for sale - ziprasidone 40mg usa purchase eskalith without prescription

buy generic anafranil - purchase citalopram generic doxepin 25mg for sale

purchase atarax online cheap - buy hydroxyzine 10mg sale cost amitriptyline

amoxiclav price - acillin us cipro 500mg drug

amoxicillin oral - order cephalexin 500mg pill buy ciprofloxacin

order zithromax 250mg for sale - where can i buy tindamax ciplox pills

cheap cleocin 150mg - order terramycin 250 mg cheap chloramphenicol generic

buy ivermectin 3mg for humans - oral levofloxacin 250mg buy generic cefaclor 500mg

buy albuterol 4mg online cheap - order allegra online cheap order generic theophylline

buy methylprednisolone 16mg - fluorometholone cost buy astelin 10ml for sale

buy desloratadine cheap - generic clarinex 5mg order albuterol inhaler

order metformin 1000mg sale - buy generic acarbose 50mg precose over the counter

prandin online - repaglinide tablet order jardiance sale

where can i buy terbinafine - order terbinafine 250mg without prescription buy cheap griseofulvin

order generic semaglutide 14 mg - buy DDAVP online cheap order DDAVP without prescription

cheap ketoconazole 200 mg - order lotrisone without prescription buy itraconazole without a prescription

purchase digoxin - order irbesartan 300mg pills lasix 40mg pill

metoprolol 100mg pill - buy micardis 80mg nifedipine 30mg without prescription

purchase hydrochlorothiazide online cheap - buy generic amlodipine online zebeta generic

purchase nitroglycerin without prescription - order nitroglycerin online diovan us

zocor armor - atorvastatin grave lipitor condition

rosuvastatin pills feeling - zetia buy corpse caduet mumble

acne medication tent - acne treatment annoy acne medication interrupt

asthma medication friendship - asthma medication lead asthma medication mend

uti medication catch - uti treatment idiot treatment for uti axe

prostatitis treatment operation - prostatitis pills recover prostatitis treatment strange

Post a comment


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.jefflewis.net/blog/jlnet-tb.cgi/160

Archives

Selling Out