« Friday Bible Blogging - 2 Kings 1 to 2 Kings 10 | Main | Follow Up, Part II: Leaving Comments on Other Sites - Birds as Dinosaurs and Fossil Evidence for Evolution »

Follow Up: Leaving Comments on Other Sites - Birds as Dinosaurs and Fossil Evidence for Evolution

Archaeopteryx - Berlin SpecimenA little less than two months ago, I left a couple comments on the blog, Across the Fruited Plain, in the entries, Are Dinosaurs Alive Today As Birds?: Refuting Archaeopteryx as "Evidence" for Evolution and Refuting Fossil "Evidence" for Evolution: The Data is NOT in the Strata. After about a week with my comments being held up in moderation, I decided to post them on this site in the entry, Leaving Comments on Other Sites - Birds as Dinosaurs and Fossil Evidence for Evolution. As I wrote in that entry, "Despite it not being a particularly active blog, I caught a case of SIWOTI syndrome and couldn't resist commenting."

Well, the writer of the blog has finally approved my comments and left a couple responses of his own. Unfortunately, so far, the discussion hasn't been particularly productive. In my first comment to his entry on fossil evidence for evolution, I was trying to correct his misrepresentations and misunderstandings of the science. Here's his initial response, in full.

Hello Jeff!

Thank you for your message.
You have made many knowledge claims, but since we do not know each other and I don't know what your epistemological groundings are, my question is, can you be wrong about everything you claim to know?

If you follow this blog at all, you can probably guess at my answer. I started off by saying that "Of course I could be wrong," and then gave a brief explanation of the sort I've made numerous times on this blog - that absolute certainty is impossible, but we can have varying levels of confidence in different ideas (for an example, see my essay, Confidence in Scientific Knowledge, or the related, but not quite as relevant, Confidence in Historical Knowledge)

His followup began in a very unpromising manner, "Therefore, if you could be wrong about everything you claim to know, then it follows that you do not know anything." It then went on from there with different variations on the theme that I've somehow admitted that knowledge is impossible because certainty is impossible.

My next reply wasn't as polite as perhaps it could have been (I lead off by asking, "Are you being obtuse on purpose?"), but it was mostly constructive and civil. I basically said that I wasn't going to get drawn into a discussion on epistemology when his own post was originally about evidence for evolution, and then reiterated my original points.

He also responded briefly to my comment on the bird entry, with a portion of his response wondering "how two creatures, who could not be more biologically different, are directly linked spontaneously through Macro Evolution". I responded with a comment listing the common features of dinosaurs and birds, but I now notice that that comment of mine is held up in moderation. Hopefully he'll approve it relatively soon.

I'll see how the conversation goes. I'm hoping he'll stay on topic with his original posts and discuss evidence for evolution. If he goes back into all the post-modern mumbo jumbo, I don't think I'll have the stomach to keep the conversation going.


Dinosaurs were made on day 6 alongside the various land creatures, including Adam and Eve. Noah took delegates of a wide range of land creatures on the Ark.

order atorvastatin 80mg generic atorvastatin 80mg oral atorvastatin 10mg oral

brand ciprofloxacin - where to buy trimethoprim without a prescription augmentin pills

buy baycip pill - buy generic keflex over the counter order augmentin 1000mg generic

buy ciplox tablets - buy chloramphenicol tablets buy erythromycin 500mg

generic flagyl 400mg - buy cefaclor online cheap azithromycin 500mg sale

ivermectin 3 mg for people - order sumycin 500mg for sale buy generic sumycin

purchase valtrex online - nateglinide order online acyclovir buy online

buy ampicillin cheap ampicillin pills amoxil price

metronidazole pill - buy generic metronidazole azithromycin 250mg sale

furosemide 100mg tablet - order candesartan 16mg without prescription capoten 120mg canada

metformin 1000mg drug - generic lincomycin order generic lincomycin 500 mg

retrovir 300mg for sale - glucophage 500mg tablet allopurinol 300mg generic

where can i buy clozapine - famotidine 40mg drug famotidine 20mg for sale

order quetiapine 50mg pill - order sertraline 100mg sale where can i buy eskalith

buy clomipramine 25mg online cheap - purchase tofranil without prescription doxepin 25mg ca

atarax online - purchase endep for sale order endep 10mg online cheap

buy augmentin no prescription - order generic augmentin 625mg cipro online buy

amoxil pills - erythromycin oral cipro 500mg pill

buy azithromycin 500mg pills - tetracycline uk ciplox 500mg drug

order cleocin 150mg - brand oxytetracycline 250mg chloramphenicol pills

stromectol without prescription - can you buy stromectol over the counter order cefaclor 250mg without prescription

buy ventolin pills for sale - albuterol inhalator sale theophylline 400 mg pills

medrol 8 mg tablet - buy zyrtec order azelastine generic

how to get clarinex without a prescription - desloratadine us albuterol 4mg without prescription

purchase metformin online - precose us buy acarbose 50mg generic

buy repaglinide 1mg pills - order jardiance for sale buy jardiance generic

buy semaglutide online - glucovance uk buy cheap generic desmopressin

lamisil 250mg uk - buy terbinafine 250mg pill buy generic grifulvin v over the counter

nizoral online - sporanox oral how to buy sporanox

buy famciclovir 500mg for sale - valaciclovir order valaciclovir 1000mg cost

brand lanoxin - brand calan 240mg furosemide online

lopressor cost - how to get benicar without a prescription order adalat generic

microzide us - where can i buy bisoprolol bisoprolol 10mg price

nitroglycerin drug - purchase nitroglycerin online cheap buy diovan 80mg pill

simvastatin realize - gemfibrozil watcher lipitor evident

crestor hurry - pravachol basil caduet top

asthma medication overhead - asthma medication twice asthma treatment without

acne treatment marsh - acne treatment dispose acne treatment hell

prostatitis pills short - pills for treat prostatitis thieve pills for treat prostatitis length

uti medication player - treatment for uti sleeve uti antibiotics rate

Post a comment


TrackBack URL for this entry:


Selling Out