« Tabbed Browsing | Main | A New Addition to the Family »

Texas Science Standards Review Panel

TEA LogoOh boy, it looks like we're in for an ugly mess down here in Texas. For a bit of background - the current chairman of the Texas State Board of Education, Don McLeroy, is a creationist, who has openly advocated the teaching of Intelligent Design in schools (transcript & recording). Last year, Chris Comer, the director of science curriculum for the Texas Education Agency, was forced to resign after forwarding an e-mail announcment of a lecture by Barbara Forrest critical of Intelligent Design. This past May, McLeroy pulled some shenanigans with a last minute cut and paste job of the English standards - having the BoE approve the new standards before anyone had sufficient time to review them, all after a three year process by teachers and experts to develop the new standards. At the end of that post, I wrote, "And don't forget that the science standards are the next in line to be reviewed. If the board can be so underhanded on a topic as uncontroversial as English, I fear just what stunts they're going to pull when it comes to subjects like biology and geology."

Now, the Board of Education has just named the six people who will be on the Texas Science Standards Review Panel:

  • David Hillis, professor of integrative biology and director of the Center of Computational Biology and Bioinformatics at the University of Texas at Austin;
  • Ronald K. Wetherington, professor of anthropology at Southern Methodist University and director of the Center for Teaching Excellence;
  • Gerald Skoog, professor and dean emeritus of the College of Education at Texas Tech and co-director of the Center for Integration of Science Education and Research;
  • Stephen Meyer, director of the Discovery Institute's Center for Science and Culture from Washington state;
  • Ralph Seelke, an ID proponent and biology professor at the University of Wiconsin, Superior;
  • Charles Garner, an ID proponent and chemistry professor from Baylor.

The first three of those members are the type of people you'd expect on a science standards review panel. But the last three are certainly worrying, especially given the past actions of the BoE. For anyone unfamiliar with the Discovery Institute, it is nominally* a conservative think tank, whose main purpose seems to be promotion of Intelligent Design and attempts to discredit evolution. Meyer, Seelke, and Garner, have all signed the Discovery Institute's "Dissent from Darwinism" statement. For an idea of how relevant that list actually is, consider Project Steve. Meyer and Seelke are even co-athors of the book,
Explore Evolution: The Arguments For and Against Neo-Darwinism. For a good review of the Discovery Institute and this book, take a look at the review on ars technica. The conclusion, although a little less than polite, sums up the book pretty nicely:

But the book doesn't only promote stupidity, it demands it. In every way except its use of the actual term, this is a creationist book, but its authors are expecting that legislators and the courts will be too stupid to notice that, or to remember that the Supreme Court has declared teaching creationism an unconstitutional imposition of religion. As laws similar to Louisiana's resurface in other states next year, we can only hope that legislators choose not to live down to the low expectations of EE's authors.

I'd hope I wouldn't have to mention that evolution is in fact true, and that it's well supported by evidence and the scientific community, but unfortunately, with the state of things right now, I think I do have to say that. For a discussion of some of that evidence, take a look at a previous blog entry of mine, A (Somewhat) Brief Introduction to Evolution.

While the current mantra of ID proponents seems to be to teach the strengths and weaknesses of evolution, you have to question their motives when they say that. On the face of it, it doesn't sound too bad. Science is not a dogmatic acceptance of the teachings of your mentors - it's all about questioning the world around you and looking for evidence. Questioning the weaknesses of a theory is where you find the interesting discoveries. However, creationists tend to single out evolution with this approach. Currently, our understanding of gravity is a whole lot worse than our understanding of evolution, but you don't hear an outcry for schools to teach Intelligent Falling, or to point out the strengths and weaknesses of that theory. You also have to question just what will be taught, considering what creationists suppose are weaknesses of evolutionary theory. When you still have people asking 'what use is half an eye?', you can just imagine what they'd want the science curriculum to be. I'm not saying the review panel is that ignorant, but consider that it will be up to individual teachers to present these weaknesses.

Anyway, if you live in Texas, or if you just promote reality based education, there are several resources for this issue:

*I use the word nominally here, because it's more of a propaganda institute than anything else.


lipitor 20mg oral order lipitor 80mg pills how to get atorvastatin without a prescription

cipro generic - buy ciprofloxacin generic augmentin canada

order ciprofloxacin 500mg generic - augmentin uk augmentin without prescription

flagyl 200mg without prescription - buy cefaclor zithromax without prescription

purchase ciplox generic - buy ciplox 500 mg generic buy erythromycin 500mg sale

order valacyclovir generic - order generic diltiazem 180mg order acyclovir 800mg pills

fda ivermectin - order aczone for sale sumycin 250mg generic

buy metronidazole 200mg pills - buy azithromycin 250mg sale buy zithromax 250mg generic

cheap ampicillin vibra-tabs for sale cheap amoxicillin generic

order furosemide for sale - buy tacrolimus 1mg pill buy captopril 25 mg pill

order glycomet 500mg pill - buy epivir tablets order lincocin 500mg generic

order generic zidovudine 300mg - lamivudine brand zyloprim 300mg over the counter

clozapine 50mg without prescription - amaryl order pepcid price

seroquel drug - cost desyrel cheap eskalith

buy clomipramine no prescription - cheap remeron 15mg cheap doxepin 75mg

buy atarax 25mg pills - buy buspar pill buy endep tablets

amoxiclav pills - trimethoprim generic ciprofloxacin price

cheap generic amoxil - ceftin over the counter cipro 500mg drug

cleocin online - oxytetracycline 250 mg pills buy generic chloramphenicol online

buy azithromycin 500mg pill - buy generic tetracycline purchase ciprofloxacin without prescription

ivermectin order online - stromectol uk cefaclor oral

how to buy albuterol - order promethazine 25mg generic theo-24 Cr 400 mg cheap

medrol 16mg tablets - where can i buy cetirizine buy astelin nasal spray

desloratadine online order - order clarinex 5mg generic order ventolin generic

micronase 5mg drug - cost glipizide forxiga order online

buy glycomet 500mg for sale - purchase januvia acarbose where to buy

prandin pill - order prandin 2mg generic order empagliflozin 10mg online

order terbinafine 250mg generic - terbinafine medication grifulvin v brand

buy generic rybelsus 14 mg - order rybelsus 14mg online cheap desmopressin price

buy nizoral 200 mg pills - buy ketoconazole 200 mg generic purchase sporanox generic

famciclovir generic - zovirax where to buy valcivir where to buy

digoxin canada - purchase labetalol sale order furosemide 100mg for sale

microzide us - order bisoprolol 5mg generic pill zebeta 10mg

buy lopressor pills for sale - buy adalat pills purchase adalat for sale

buy nitroglycerin online - buy lozol 1.5mg online diovan order

zocor hedge - simvastatin room buy atorvastatin generic

crestor pills torment - buy pravachol 20mg sale caduet pills full

acne medication think - acne medication slave acne medication tea

inhalers for asthma dish - inhalers for asthma people asthma treatment research

uti antibiotics how - uti antibiotics round treatment for uti stranger

prostatitis medications dozen - prostatitis treatment spell pills for treat prostatitis adventure

Post a comment


TrackBack URL for this entry:


Selling Out